Tesla Model X vs. Model Y: Which One Should You Rent?

Tesla's Model X and Model Y are both outstanding SUVs with unique features. If you’re looking for a luxurious, high-end electric vehicle (EV) for a large family or off-road adventures, the Tesla Model X is a perfect choice. However, if you prioritize practicality, affordability, and a balance between performance and range, the Model Y is ideal for you.

10 Key Comparisons Between Tesla Model X and Model Y

Price Point: Luxurious or Budget-Friendly?

• Model X: Starting at around $98,490, the Model X is a full-fledged luxury EV.

• Model Y: Starting at $49,490, the Model Y offers a quintessential Tesla experience at a more budget-friendly price.

Top Speed and Range: Speed Demons or Efficient Cruisers?

• Model X: In its Plaid trim, the Model X has a 100 kWh battery, offering a range of 348 miles.

• Model Y: The base Model Y features a 60 kWh battery with a 279-mile range, and the Long Range variant extends to 330 miles.

Charging Speed: Quick Charge or Slow Burn?

Both models support 11 kW AC and 250 kW DC fast charging.

• Model X: Full charge in just over 10 hours with a Level 2 charger and 30 minutes at a fast charger.

• Model Y: Full charge in 6.5 hours at home and 25 minutes at a fast charger.

Drivetrain: Performance Powerhouses or Efficiency Experts?

• Model Y: Rear-wheel drive, nimble, great for city commutes.

• Model X: All-wheel drive as standard, better for off-road driving.

Dimensions and Size: Garage Fit or Street Dominator?

• Model X: Larger and bulkier, measuring 5,057 mm in length and 1,999 mm in width.

• Model Y: More compact, with a length of 4,751 mm and a width of 1,921 mm.

Cargo Volume: Luggage Tetris or Room to Spare?

• Model X: Offers 37.1 cubic feet of space behind the rear row and a total of 85.1 cubic feet with seats folded.

• Model Y: Provides 30.2 cubic feet of cargo space with seats up and 72.1 cubic feet with seats down.

Seating Space and Interior: Family Haulers or Solo Sanctuaries?

• Model X: Can seat up to 7 passengers with a third-row option and has a spacious interior with multiple screens.

• Model Y: Offers a comfortable five-seater configuration with a single central screen.

Design and Style: Falcon Wings or Everyday Chic?

• Model X: Features dramatic Falcon-wing doors for easy access to the second row.

• Model Y: Adopts a more conventional SUV style focused on practicality and driving dynamics.

Reliability: Road Warriors or Repair Shop Regulars?

• Model Y: Predicted reliability score of 73 out of 100 from J.D. Power.

• Model X: No predicted reliability score yet but offers a longer powertrain warranty (eight years/150,000 miles).

Safety: Fortress on Wheels or Not?

• Model Y: Safety score of 9.9 from U.S. News.

• Model X: Awaiting safety scores from relevant authorities.

  
  

Tesla Showdown: Model X vs. Y - Key Specs at a Glance